Harvard Wong's comment on SERBADK. All Comments

Harvard Wong
27 Like · Reply
笑死。讲KPMG raise 的red flag 是在琐碎的问题上,从而导致股价大跌而造成严重损失,失去公信力,失去信誉。

既然是琐碎的问题,就应该正视问题,马上委托独立auditor 来搞定啊。搞定了才来提告KPMG也不迟啊。

在无法证明自己的公司账目没问题的情况下,反告对方失职?这更叫人难以信服啊!

讲到公司有多好,自己账目都搞不清楚,够力咯!
Show more
YinG
不懂他们搞什么 委托独立auditor还是kpmg自己提给他们的意见 结果过了整个月还没委托E&Y 整个月不懂在琢磨淋
3 Like · 3 years · translate
Yao Ty
有票的记得快点抛售。。。。。下跌是是很恐怖的
2 Like · 3 years · translate
renoma 1443
epf 的操作才是关键
3 Like · 3 years · translate
126 John
对啊下跌挺恐怖,看你叫买手套很久了,阴跌不恐怖吗?
Like · 3 years · translate
Reddit Reddit
到最后也没拿出什么能证明清白...感觉贼喊捉贼..其实问题很简单..报告一天不出很难相信他们公司没问题...一直拖不知道想掩盖什么...
Like · 3 years · translate
Lim Horng
砂捞越的股都出事,政治阴谋明显,kpmg因为1mdb案件,出卖sb理由充足。这也可以解释为什么kpmg没有因为1mdb而被提控
1 Like · 3 years · translate
Wang LC
Lim Horng 大神, 现在你终于承认蛇霸有问题了
2 Like · 3 years · translate
Unknown
个人觉得KPMG after raise red flag了经理了50多天接近两个月了都没有回应Serba. Serba转告也是理所当然的事情。Serba想要赶快解决这些问题才可以继续下去。KPMG raise red flag是对的,但是他们接下来没有更近任何消息,这到觉得不应该这样。Serba 只所以会转告就是因为这一点。谁对谁错还是要等到auditor report 出来才懂
Show more
4 Like · 3 years · translate
Lim Horng
政治问题早就讲了。sb敢sue毕马威,肯定是有备而来。sc已经介入调查,只等报告出来。丁丁就算敢对pbb开刀但也不敢做的太绝,最多只是把砂捞越州选拖到和全国大选一起举行。
2 Like · 3 years · translate
Harvard Wong
赌徒是不需要知道,也不用关心SB的账目有没有问题的。all in 就对了。
1 Like · 3 years · translate
YUH FATT VONG
现在你是选玛希丁还是唔通?自己看着办
Like · 3 years · translate
Harvard Wong
unknown, 如果没问题, KPMG 没有任何理由不回应 SB, 吃饱没事找事做。SB 提告KPMG 是解决不了更本的问题的。

问题是账目!问题是账目!

要求独立审核是最快的方法,不是诉讼。司法程序需要很长一段时期,浪费时间+金钱。
Show more
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
i saw they did clarify one by one thru announcement oledi, y ppl still say not explain n unsolved? pending apa lagi?
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
KPMG purposely no reply even Serba dah clarify wit them many times, tis is wat i saw in announcement...dun listen to ppl outside talk bull n cock...KPMG yang not pro now...keep mute their mouth...
1 Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
Serba is 佛都有火, pay KPMG gaji , entertain them, explain to them but they just keep quiet, tis is wat i read frm press conf ystr......
2 Like · 3 years · translate
Shawn Ch'ng
maybe internal politic too
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
wat i heard ystr was appoint EY is KPMG idea, Serba ystr says actually is KPMG job to review n revert aftet Serba explain, y Serba need listen to KPMG to complete the task that KPMG not done but was paid and let EY accomplish de job
Show more
Like · 3 years · translate
Harvard Wong
then why SB yet to appoint EY to settle the so call small problem?

as I said, SB should settle the audit issue first regardless is EY or any other auditor then only claim their losses from KPMG. that's the correct step.
Show more
3 Like · 3 years · translate
126 John
Why talk so much here? Just give review to KPMG will do
Like · 3 years · translate
Kaiba AA
aplointing Shafee already roughly guessed the real issue in it la.
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
Ystr Serba replied oledi, review n answer dah given to KPMG, ini KPMG was hiding in Shell, dun sign off n keep quiet...ask Serba to get EY redo de review....Serba thinks KPMG is running frm their duty to complete de task...y shld Serba listen to them again to hire EY, sue them direct to awake them in Court is the last resort
Show more
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
Serba oledi prove they hv done nothing wrong, now is KPMG turn to prove in court whether they hv breach their standard or duty as auditor for not comply to timeline n etc
Like · 3 years · translate
Kaiba AA
ya la ya la. Win the court case la. With Shafee and political involved, whatever the outcome, down inside the heart of investors there no more trust. If you appoint some other lawyer that have no graft case and not involved with politics, people still will support. Too bad, the bad impression is too deep.
Show more
1 Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
Lawyer is pro, doing their duty to defence for client whether they r murderer, raper, or etc...we cannot judge lawyer in tis view, like tis we no need lawyer n law oledi......
1 Like · 3 years · translate
Harvard Wong
that's why I say, settle the audit issue, not court case!

don't give your conclusion too soon.
3 Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
audit issue cannot settle one if Serba reply them 1 by 1, and KPMG refuse to face them n revert....Need wait for outcome frm security comm...if Serba took de step to sue, meaning they hv confidence to prove KPMG wrong....tis is wat i see
Show more
Like · 3 years · translate
126 John
Just put urself into the situation, if the auditor caused so much problem to you business, as a boss u also will sue the audit firm la. It damaged about RM3b of its market capitalisation, damaged reputation and credit rating, nothing wrong to take legal action first and settle the accounting issue later. Both can run in the same time.
Show more
2 Like · 3 years · translate
Harvard Wong
Why audit issue can be solved? that's the fundamental problem!

Solving this, everything is going be alright. that's all.

not court case, this never be good to SB even they won the case.
Show more
1 Like · 3 years · translate
飞鸿腾达
蛇粑几时才能起呢?你的股出问题咯还不知死
Like · 3 years · translate
Kaiba AA
so I assume Joanne will think that Najib is innocent and totally zero corruption from all the suit against him. Hmm... this is education problem now I guess.
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
Sori i dun think Najib is innocent oh...but lawyer job is to defend for client
1 Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
oni judge hv right to judge who right o wrong, not lawyer not anyone of us
Like · 3 years · translate
Kaiba AA
Even judge say Najib is innocent, I believe based on your wording and thinking should be believe Najib is innocent too. But the whole world already have their own judgement in the heart. Politics can affect the outcome, in Malaysia anything is possible. But the truth is always buried deep inside our heart. So it's the same as Serba. With Shafee and political linked, even if judge let Serba win, how many people in % you think that investors believe the court? Is up to your own and our judgement.
Show more
Like · 3 years · translate
Kaiba AA
Unless the lawyer not Shafee, chairman not linked to any political party whos famous for bad things. I will still have some believe in Serba and the decision made by the court. But with these crooks helping to defend serba, sorry no thanks on whatever outcome it is.
Show more
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
Even Serba won the case oso cannot escape from security commission. Now SC is reviewing their acc, we shall trust SC is fair n square and gv us more reliable answer.....
Like · 3 years · translate
Kaiba AA
Once you pulled in political influences, especially with the famous with crooks, how to gather confidence of fairness. Even SC says ntg wrong, but with those crooks around, how to 100% believe. Why they go and team with those people who's image is not even good.
Show more
Like · 3 years · translate
Joanne Tan
SC result is the most reliable, if ppl still lose confident then no choice lorr..they cannot bribe SC wat
Like · 3 years · translate
Harvard Wong
Joanne, that's not the function of SC. they judge base on facts and evidence given from other parties.

that's why SB should settle the audit issue in any possible way instead of bringing KPMG into court.
Like · 3 years · translate
ny Jin
Win the court case, no audit report, still will go to PN17,
Like · 3 years · translate
Harvard Wong
Joanne, even their INEDs resigned because of disagree of bringing KPMG to court. that's why I say, that was a wrong action, they should have settle the audit issue if nothing to hide. court case should be last option.
1 Like · 3 years · translate